That One CrawlerDaddy mode

Keywords check

Keyword cannibalization: how to find and fix competing pages

Keyword cannibalization happens when two or more pages on your site target the same main keyword. They compete with each other, Google flips between them, and none ranks as well as one strong page would. Fix it by choosing one page to own the keyword and merging, redirecting or re-angling the others.

By Updated · 1 min read

Why it matters

Blogs cannibalize themselves naturally: you write about a topic, then a year later write about it again. Each post earns some links and some relevance, but split across several URLs it rarely adds up to a top result.

How to fix it

  1. Open the Keywords tab to see groups of pages sharing a main keyword.

  2. For each group, pick the strongest page (best content, most links) as the owner.

  3. Merge useful content from the others into it and 301-redirect them.

  4. Or keep them, but retarget each at a distinct angle with new titles and H1s.

  5. Link from the other pages to the owner, using the keyword as anchor text.

How That One Crawler checks it

  • Keyword cannibalizationWarning

    Several of your pages target the same main keyword, so they compete with each other and none ranks as well as one strong page would.

    Fix: Pick one page to own the keyword. Merge or redirect the others, or retarget them at different angles.

Frequently asked questions

Is keyword cannibalization always bad?

Not always. If two pages answer genuinely different intents, both can rank. It's a problem when they say the same thing for the same search.

How do you detect it without Search Console?

We work out each page's main keyword from its title, H1, URL and text. Pages only count when they target it in the title plus the H1 or URL. Category pages, the homepage and contact or legal pages are left out. Search Console confirms which pages compete.

Find every page with this problem

Free, no signup, results in a couple of minutes. Your scans stay in your browser.