# Broken pages (404 errors): how to find and fix them

> Pages that return 404 or 5xx errors are dead ends for readers and search engines. Learn how to find broken pages on your blog and fix them with redirects.

Source: https://thatonecrawler.houseofnamus.com/checks/broken-pages-404 · Updated 2026-10-22 · By Suman Debnath (https://sumandebnath.houseofnamus.com)

A broken page returns an error such as 404 (not found) or 500 (server error) instead of content. Readers hit a dead end and search engines eventually drop the URL. Restore the page, or 301-redirect it to the most relevant live page and update links that point at it.

## Why it matters

Broken pages appear when posts are deleted, slugs change, or migrations miss URLs. Any links and rankings the old URL earned are wasted, and internal links pointing at it send readers into a wall. Server errors also suggest hosting trouble that affects crawling.

## How to fix it

1. Filter your scan by “Broken page” to list every URL returning an error.
2. If the content moved, add a 301 redirect from the old URL to its new home.
3. If it's gone for good, redirect to the closest relevant page, or let it 404 if nothing fits.
4. Update internal links and sitemap entries that still point at broken URLs.
5. Investigate 5xx errors with your host: they usually mean overload or a crashing plugin.
6. Make missing pages answer with a real 404 status, not a “Page not found” page that says 200 OK (a soft 404).

## Frequently asked questions

### What is a soft 404?

A page that tells visitors it doesn't exist but tells crawlers everything is fine (status 200). Search engines may index the error page, and AI agents can't tell it's missing. Return a real 404 or 410 instead.

### Do 404 errors hurt SEO?

A few 404s for genuinely removed pages are normal. They hurt when they waste links pointing at them or when important pages break by accident.

### Should I redirect every 404 to the homepage?

No. Google treats irrelevant redirects to the homepage much like a 404 anyway. Redirect only to a page that genuinely replaces the old one.

## Related checks

- [Broken links: how to find and fix dead links on your blog](https://thatonecrawler.houseofnamus.com/checks/broken-links)
- [Redirects and redirect chains: how to clean them up](https://thatonecrawler.houseofnamus.com/checks/redirects)
- [Orphan pages: how to find pages with no internal links](https://thatonecrawler.houseofnamus.com/checks/orphan-pages)

---

That One Crawler: Free SEO audit tool for blogs. Crawl your whole site to find broken links, thin content, duplicate titles, keyword cannibalization and AI search gaps. Run a free audit at https://thatonecrawler.houseofnamus.com. All pages: https://thatonecrawler.houseofnamus.com/llms.txt
